We Can Assist You with Auto, Home and Business Insurance in Fond Du Lac, Waupun, Ripon, Oshkosh and Areas Around Plymouth

Delivering the best in personal service…at the lowest possible cost since 1973

about-us-building-croppedBehnke Insurance was founded on one guiding principle: Providing the lowest insurance prices without sacrificing the highest commitment to service. We’ve never shifted focus as we’ve built our reputation of professional trust one lasting relationship at a time – one family, one entrepreneur, one new driver, one new dream. Delivering on the promise of tomorrow with sound advice in a changing world, expert care, and consistent results, we treat your insurance needs as our determined goal.  Until you are secure, we haven’t done our job!

Fond du Lac to Oshkosh, Plymouth to Ripon, Waupun and beyond:
Behnke Insurance serves clients throughout Wisconsin

about-us-At Behnke Insurance, Inc, we offer insurance throughout Fond du Lac, Oshkosh, Waupun, Ripon, Plymouth, and all over the great state of Wisconsin.  Our agents have helped countless families just like yours gain the security that comes from knowing your policy truly safeguards all your most valued assets.  From life insurance to homeowners, from business and commercial insurance to auto insurance, our reliable agents have the proven experience to field all your coverage needs – and save you money in the process.  Using the most advanced technology systems to ensure you the quickest processing of your claims, as well as offering you online payment options, we remain committed to continually improving your quality of service.

Don’t wait to secure your vital interests against an uncertain future.  Call now – we are here for you!



Owner – Agent

ScottPScott combines a professional history of advanced education and training with a proven record of prioritizing the personal values of his diverse clients.  Having graduated as an “Outstanding Student” in 1979 with an Associate Degree in Applied Science of Insurance from North Central Technical College (NTCI), his standards of excellence extend through every aspect of his business practice. He has been a licensed insurance agent since 1978, is a member of the Professional Insurance Agents (PIA), and serves on the Agent’s Advisory Board for commercial insurance with West Bend Mutual. Scott’s broad base of experience handling commercial health, group health and life insurance, personal insurance, as well as surety and fidelity bonds, offers a unique perspective for addressing a variety of customer needs.

Scott is an avid race fan, and spends his leisure time enjoying many outdoor activities along with his wife Mari, daughter Taryn, and son Matt.


Owner – Agent

StacyAfter earning his Insurance Degree in Madison, Stacy became a licensed agent in 1987 and came to work for the family business. Stacy offers his insurance expertise across the full spectrum of the insurance field, including personal and commercial lines, personal health, life and disability coverage, group health and life coverage. Stacy is a member of the Professional Agents of Wisconsin, with the distinction of participating in the Young Agent’s Conference of Wisconsin for several years.

In addition to providing top quality service to our customers, he is a member of the Fond du Lac Noon Kiwanis Club, and has been an active member of the Town of Fond du Lac Fire Department and First Responder since 1988.  Stacy has the unique gift of being an expert in financial and insurance details balanced with an outgoing love of people, whether spending time with his wife Angie and two children, making new friends or enjoying lifelong friendships.  In his free time you may find him out snowmobiling, along with fellow members of the Fond du Lac Snowflyers Club.


Insurance Agent

BethBeth brings a storied career to her insurance practice.  A licensed agent for over 22 years, her insurance practice began in the Milwaukee area before joining our team here in 1996.  While an expert in several areas of insurance service, she currently serves as our personal lines specialist, offering her wealth of experience to homeowners and personal automobile insurance coverage, including our high-risk policyholders.  The secret to her success and satisfaction as an outstanding agent is the personal connection she enjoys with her customers, building relationships and friendships that last throughout the years.

When she’s not serving here in the office, both Beth and her husband Mike are avid Harley enthusiasts, enjoying riding and camping with family and friends.


Office Manager, Customer Service Rep, & Accounting and License Agent

CindyCindy is the rare team member who is a jack of all trades – and a master of every one!  She has been a licensed agent since 2000, assisting customers in their initial claim reporting and in making crucial changes to their coverage.  Yet she also handles all of our office’s administrative elements, such as payroll and accounting, and is the real face of our agency to our valued family of customers.  She has been a part of the insurance industry since 1975, and a cherished member of Behnke Insurance since 1984.

Cindy has a love for reading, averaging 35 to 40 books a year, as well as an adventurous traveling spirit.  Of all her travels though, she often finds the trip she enjoys most is her frequent jaunt to Milwaukee to watch her beloved Brewers slug it out on the field!